I had bought this in the dark gray and liked it pretty well, so I went back and bought the dark green, knowing other reviewers said it's not as dark as the photo. While that's true, it's a soft pine green, which is still flattering on me. The buttons aren't the same mottled/tortoise brown as my other shirt - they are a sort of "coconut shell" brown on one side and light tan on the other, and slightly curved, but they weren't all sewn on the same way, so two on one sleeve and one on the other sleeve are brown-side-up, while all the other buttons around the shirt are tan-side-up. I *might* take the three odd ones off and re-sew them so they all match, but I haven't decided. Also, the material isn't quite as soft as the gray shirt, but I'm hoping that with a few washes, it will soften a little.I'm 5'5" and a slightly soft 125 pounds and bought a small, which is still a little roomy in the torso. (I don't know what size the model could possibly be wearing since there is no extra small option. I'm bigger than the model, and the size small isn't nearly that snug on me!) The shoulder seams land a little wider than a "true" fit should, but I won't complain too much. I washed in cold and then dried on high heat to try to shrink it a little, and it did slightly. I'm hoping it won't shrink in length, since that's just right. It falls below my belt line, which I like.Overall, it's a cute shirt, but if you're as slender as the model, you won't be able to get a snug fit like the photo shows.